Asking for the Mass

I was just reading the news story from the Ephemeris column about Valley Catholics and the Latin Mass, and I had a little thought. This was one of those silly news stories that mostly goes on about how normal people don’t want the traditional Mass because it’s boring and confusing, with the strong implication that old people are the only ones who care about it. (Obviously these reporters don’t trouble to actually go to a traditional Mass before writing about it, or they’d know that the traditional movement is not merely a refuge for nostalgic old timers. It was even more clear that this reporter didn’t go to a Mass, because she included a somewhat hilarious comment from a New-Norm parishioner who was concerned that she wouldn’t be able to understand the homily if it was in Latin!)

Anyway, I’ve read a fair number of these silly stories by now, and one favorite trick is to quote priests insisting that they’ve never once gotten a request for a Latin Mass in their X number of years as a pastor. (Usually an impressive number, because of course most of the priests they talk to are older ones who are openly hostile to tradition.) Of course this is indicative of precisely nothing. If you really love the traditional Mass, you’re going to go looking for it. And anyone with remotely traditional sensibilities knows by now that it’s utterly pointless to agitate for a Traditional Latin Mass at the sort of parish where the priest uses his homily to criticize the Holy Father, where the schola has been replaced with tamborine-playing “worship band”, where the bulletin is used to discourage people from kneeling to receive Communion, etc etc. Traditionally-minded people have mostly vacated those sorts of parishes at the first opportunity. Quotes from liberal priests about how nobody’s asking for the Mass, mean about as much as quotes from drug dealers who testify that, “I don’t think anyone really has a problem with what I do. Everybody I talk to insists that I should continue selling drugs.”

Traditional Catholics have mostly stopped paying any attention to the whole idea of territorial parishes. I’ve heard arguments from New-Norm Catholics that this is a bad thing, and that it would really be good to get away from the idea of choosing a parish based on personal preference. This is not a crazy idea, and in a world in which all parishes were solidly orthodox I might get on board. As it is, taking a principled stand against parish-shopping is just a lot less important to me than finding a parish where the Blessed Sacrament is treated with respect, where heresy isn’t preached from the pulpit, and where the congregation seems to regard the Mass with the appropriate sort of prayerful awe.

Still, things aren’t like they were ten or even five years ago. The Holy Father, as well as others in the Church hierarchy, are making real efforts to bring the Traditional Latin Mass back, not only for a few fringe fanatics, but for all Catholics. As laymen we may not be able to do a huge amount to help this effort along, but perhaps we can do something. We are, after all, the class of people that the “spirit of Vatican II” folks claim to champion. So what if we made more of a point of asking for the Mass? I don’t mean that we should make ourselves irksome with extensive letter-writing campaigns, but we might try sending a letter to the rectory of our territorial parish politely suggesting that we would like it if the Traditional Latin Mass could be said there, on Sundays or as often as is possible. No doubt the result for most of us would be no reply at all, or at most a reply letting us know where the nearest Traditional Mass can be found. But at least we’d be making a start at communicating to these priests that there are actually people — including some within their own territory – who want the Traditional Latin Mass. And if they were honest, they’d have to stop telling the silly reporters that nobody ever asks for the it.

2 Responses to “Asking for the Mass”


  1. 1 John L Jun 23rd, 2008 at 5:45 am

    the point about the desirability of going to a territorial parish is an argument for the restoration of the old liturgy and the elimination of the new one. If the old liturgy is the only one on offer, then wherever you go the liturgy must be at least acceptable, and the requirement to go to your local parish makes sense. Even if you grant without conceding that the NO is acceptable, it is still the case that it retains enough options to make it impossible to guarantee an acceptable liturgy, and hence the requirement of going to the local parish cannot be imposed.

  2. 2 Clara Jun 23rd, 2008 at 10:26 am

    I agree with you, John. The people who make this argument to me (that we should all go to our territorial parishes) are New-Norm Catholics (what I used to call Novus Catholics on this blog; people who primarily assist at the Novus Ordo Mass) and they don’t necessarily have quite the same issues with it. I agree with them that it’s bad to think of Mass as something that should be adapted to my personal preferences. But of course, I don’t think of my criteria for choosing a parish as “personal preferences” but rather as objective goods — lack of heresy, greater respect for the Sacrament, and a better shaping of the sensibilities of the faithful. At the present time, that’s more important.

    When all parishes are orthodox and say the Traditional Latin Mass, I’ll probably go to my territorial parish.

Leave a Reply




Regina Sacratissimi Rosarii,
ora pro nobis

Dramatis Personae

Ambrosius
    Praeses Noster
Iacobus
    Sub-Praeses
Iosephus
    Magister Bibendi
Doctor Asinorum
    Poeta olim laureatus
Franciscus
    Praesidis Optio
Clara
    Legatus ad mulierculas


Contact Information

information
- at -
cornellsociety.org


Sententiae Legendae



Religiosae Societates



Loci Traditionalibus



Bibliopollae Catholici



Popinae Bene Edendi





Patrons of our Society


St. Louis-Marie de Montfort,
ora pro nobis

Pope St. Pius X,
ora pro nobis


Patrons of our Contributors


St. Joseph,
ora pro nobis

St. Ambrose of Milan,
ora pro nobis

St. Thomas Aquinas,
ora pro nobis

St. Francis (and St. Clare),
orate pro nobis

St. Catherine of Siena,
ora pro nobis

St. Alphonsus Ligouri,
ora pro nobis

St. John Chrysostom,
ora pro nobis
see stats