News: Sensation!!! Nabumetone Mivial valve prolapse viagra Next day delivery on phentermine Buy online viagra viagra Vaccine Online ordering viagra Written prescription for viagra Meclofenamate Phentermine gynecomastia Cheap generic cialis Viagra free pill Prazosin Lisinopril versus viagra Xanax 0.25 mg Ecotrin Phentermine effects on birth control Capoten Chromium Methimazole Lowest price phentermine with free shipping Phentermine buy order Bar gold xanax Nizatidine Non perscription generic cialis 100 mg tramadol Cialis levitra viagra compare Does viagra work Mirena Foscarnet Taking phentermine Aminophylline Xanax prescription online Xanax effect Buy Xanax Mylan xanax Online doctors perscriptions xanax steroids Pseudoephedrine Aspartame Methdilazine Cyclobenzaprine Levlen Propafenone Alesse Ultram tramadol hci tablet Buy viagra uk Thiopropazate Can woman take cialis Viagra price list Viagra online ordering Provigil Buy online securely viagra Bayer Canadian viagra Buy tramadol cheap Carvedilol Phentermine blue Viagra pill splitter Phentermine and ocular hypertension Viagra picture Filling online prescription viagra Cheap phentermine prescription Effects of viagra Cheap phentermine Pilljar phentermine Budesonide Oxycontin xanax bars percasettes and lor tabs Amiloride Clomid Purchase viagra online Dihydrotachysterol Dothiepin Omeprazole Opipramol Phentermine online diet pill Oseltamivir Carteolol Cod online tramadol Phentermine guaranteed overnight shipping Discount priced viagra Ofloxacin Drug testing and tramadol Vicodin m360 Ursodiol Half price viagra Viagra strip poker flash games Lowest price on phentermine Phentermine 37.5 tablet Phentermine no prescription Generic viagra overnight shipping Bush inauguration speech draft viagra bastard of Order phentermine online without perscription Ecstasy Ambien overnight Clotrimazole Opium Cialis for woman Perphenazine Phenytoin Order cialis uk Viagra for woman study Desyrel Phentermine picture Lowest cost phentermine Mobic Anxiety disorder xanax Gemfibrozil Phentermine 37.5 no prescription Nutmeg Tramadol uses Elocon Fioricet information Discount generic cialis Methacycline Generic viagra cheap Inform your doctor medication phentermine dose weight Diet diet dieting phentermine pill Methocarbamol Riboflavin Cyclamate Penicillamine Donepezil Trimethobenzamide Buying viagra online Tramadol ultram Etretinate Phentermine medication Anisotropine Betaxolol Isometheptene Esmolol Phentermine 15 mg Viagra without prescription Phentermine dangers Nortriptyline Lincomycin Generic name online qoclick tramadol Olanzapine Blindness cialis Prempro Luvox and xanax Picture of xanax pill Xanax valium Generic vicodin Viagra shelf life Phentermine in jonesboro arkansas Carbachol Amoxicillin Casanthranol Piperazine Phentermine 30 Does viagra woman work Phentermine not working Cheap tramadol 180 Online viagra sales Filing income tax tramadol Levoxyl Phentermine overnight no perscription Tranylcypromine Viagra price comparison Phentermine dangerous Differin Cheapest secure delivery cialis uk Diet hcl phentermine pill Dimethindene Hydrocodone apap Levorphanol Order xanax cod Lunesta Ampicillin Vicodin effects Triprolidine Ambien rx Lethal dosage of xanax Clarithromycin Order cialis Low dose of viagra Methazolamide Viagra testimony Appetite suppressants equivelant to phentermine Cod overnight tramadol Adipex between difference phentermine Soma seed Lynestrenol Purchase phentermine Losec Dulcolax Herbal substitute viagra How fast does phentermine work Phenoxybenzamine Cialis price comparison Phentermine 37.5mg tablets Ups cod phentermine From generic india viagra Order xanax overnight Canadian online pharmacy xanax Tramadol drug interactions Order phentermine online uk Maprotiline Phentermine and carbs Pediacare Long term effects of phentermine use Online consultation xanax Kaopectate Cash on delivery phentermine Ssri phentermine heart Online phentermine prescription Sumatriptan Cephapirin Phentermine low price Cialis sample Cefonicid Xanax online cheap Discount phentermine online Viagra cialis generic Macrodantin Dextroamphetamine Cialis info Alprazolam Canada cialis Herbal viagra alternative review Xanax side effects Tocainide Estrace Octreotide Viagra conviaindications 150 tramadol Carbenicillin Iodoquinol Viagra info Hexachlorophene Viagra in canada L arginine natural viagra Reglan Soma fm Cheep tramadol paris france Buy online order viagra Viagra women Overnight tramadol Amoxil Cyber pharmacy viagra Pentamidine Divalproex Phentermine for less Mephenytoin Drug test tramadol Fexofenadine Does xanax show up on drug tests Mebendazole Drug prescription tramadol Phentermine no perscription Paxil with phentermine interactions Simethicone Hydroxychloroquine Electricity Buy cod diet phentermine pill Ergocalciferol Generic viagra and generic drug Drug phentermine testing Keyword tramadol Adalat Buy florida in phentermine Buy phentermine prozac Cholecalciferol Ambien medication Foradil Neomycin Phentermine 15mg Tramadol prescription 50 hcl mg tramadol Cod phentermine shipped Prescription free viagra Cheaper viagra levivia cyalis Cephalexin Hydrocodone medication Taking phentermine with antidepressants Cialis vs viagra Indinavir Aminopterin Ativan xanax Discount phentermine price Order xanax Ship free viagra sample Phenytoin interaction with xanax Buy online viagra securely Ethinamate Fenoprofen Phentermine free shipping 90 supply Cheap phentermine perscription Effects viagra Phentermine 37.5 mg no prescription Erectile dysfunction viagra Orlistat Cialis injury lawyer ohio Free generic viagra samples Famotidine Buy cheap phentermine yellow Best price phentermine Buy phentermine online cheap Cephalexin Oxycontin xanax bars perclesept and lortab Cheapest phentermine online free shipping Online pharmacies with doctor consultation for viagra Ambien cr Best viagra prices online Viagra investigator Fioricet order Effects long side term xanax Order phentermine on line Natural viagra type alternatives Phentermine pharmacys online Epinephrine Fioricet phentermine shipping Phentermine diet pill Colesevelam Ephedrine Order viagra buying viagra uk Approval cialis fda Chlortetracycline Meridia Lowest price viagra Diet phentermine Ambien on line Phentermine without prescription Cheap xanax Is viagra safe for woman Phentermine airborne express+cod Viagra drug interaction Tretinoin Canadian pharmacy viagra Tramadol dosage Xanax gg 258 Trandolapril Methscopolamine Triamcinolone Chlorothiazide Adipex phentermine pill Natural alternative to viagra Abbr href rel title title viagra Paxil Cialis compared to viagra Nadolol Grapefruit xanax Effects of viagra on women Phentermine low prices Anafranil Vicodin dosage Ionamin What happens when women take viagra Tramadol no prescription Loperamide 120 cheap tramadol Noroxin Tessalon Viagra usage Clonazepam Phentermine use Xanax photo Imiquimod Phentermine with free shipping Tramadol withdrawal Terazosin Buy phentermine shipped usps Diamox Phentermine weight loss pills Methadone Cialis free trial Thalidomide Primaquine Asparaginase Half life of xanax Free shipping cheap phentermine Phentermine fastin Guaifenesin Herbal alternative viagra Thyroid Viagra dosages Macrobid Buy lvivhostcom online viagra viagra Phentermine ingredients Ethoheptazine Xanax liver damage Vicodin and alcohol On line viagra Viagra soft tabs Terbinafine Where to buy viagra online How long does xanax stay in your system Add a link viagra Cialis levitra sales viagra Free viagra without a perscription Pilocarpine Celebrex Prescription tramadol Is it safe to take prozac and phentermine Vicodin health Pfizer xanax pills Phentermine from the uk Gitalin Accolate Neurontin Etanercept Ethchlorvynol Levivia compared to viagra Order viagra prescription Clarithromycin Venlafaxine Meridia Finasteride Viagra pill cutter Order vicodin Online consultation phentermine Cozaar Flexeril Naprosyn Us phentermine Metformin Generic ambien Pyrilamine Online cialis 50mg viagra Linkdomain buy online viagra info domain buy onlin Ethinyl Efavirenz Prilosec Wholesale pfizer viagra Phentermine no consultation Online pharmacy and phentermine Tramadol hcl acetaminotran Alprazolam xanax Xanax withdrawl message boards Substitute viagra Drug testing xanax Mail order viagra online Buy viagra pill Xanax Levitra Viagra online pharmacy Mixing cocaine and viagra Indocin Chemical name for viagra Vytorin Bricanyl Phentermine with hoodia Leuprolide Minocycline Soma muscle Purchase cialis Calcifediol Buy Ambien Granisetron Buying phentermine without prescription Buy xanax without prescription Buy phentermine online pharmacy Ativan Betamethasone Avapro Biaxin Sofia viagra How to inject xanax pills Promethazine Viagra cialis Xanax withdrawls Viagra side affects Clopidogrel Drug interactions with cialis Actonel Phentermine online without a prescription Hydrocodone query Viagra versus levivia Phentermine credit card or cod Apcalis cialis Phentermine resin Vicodin without prescription Xanax no prescription overnight delivery Mevacor Kaolin Alternative new viagra Buy online viagra where Vicodin and pregnancy Fastin phentermine Xanax 1mg Viagra joke Mechlorethamine Phentermine resident sale virginia Cialis results Phentermine 37.5mg tablet Tramadol 377 Adipex meridia phentermine xenical Phentermine at cost with no prescription Phentermine warning How long does xanax stay in the system Buy Diazepam Phentermine phendimetrazine Grapefruit viagra Elocon Viagra interaction Enalapril Phytonadione Hydrocortisone Side effects of drug xanax Idoxuridine Pentasa Plaquenil Cheapest phentermine pill Fentanyl Side effects from viagra Order cialis online Get online viagra Viagra cialis levivia About xanax Viagra success story Viagra Hydrocodone m358 Phentermine hci Natural suppliments work like viagra Chlorpheniramine Epirubicin Buy hydrocodone overnight Dilantin Cialis effective soft tab treatment Xanax death Imitrex Cheap viagra in the uk Information viagra woman Buy cialis in the uk Veterinary use of tramadol Streptomycin 37.5 phentermine Dexbrompheniramine Valtrex Treat crohns disease with viagra Order soma online Buy cheap online viagra James thompson viagra lawsuit Buy cheap tramadol online Probenecid Alendronate Buy Didrex Zyban Online consultations and prescriptions phentermine Hydrocodone effects Quinacrine 0 buy by popl powered viagra wordpress Hydrocodone online Soma san diego Maxzide Molindone Discount soma Discount viagra online Skelaxin Fosamax Saquinavir Tinzaparin Cefdinir Penbutolol Apomorphine Online phentermine no prescription Furosemide Phentermine 37.5mg cheap Dangers of xanax and klonopin addiction Pravachol Discount phentermine to florida Buy phentermine in the uk Xanax half life Belladonna Amaryl Viagra commercial Valium Phentermine side effects Drug interaction sibutramine and phentermine Pediacare Mesoridazine Buy Zyban Phentermine compare prices Purchase soma Viagra price online Multivitamins Generic cialis softtabs Lortab and xanax without a prescription Levivia dosing compared to viagra Oxycontin xanax bars per casettes and lortabs Aricept Line pharmacy phentermine Bupropion Buy cialis in canada Amaryl Cialis levivia viagra vs vs Viagra advertisement Estrone Protriptyline Levivia vs cialis vs viagra Buy phentermine by cod Buy phentermine online with pay pal Carphenazine Dont buy on black market get viagra legally Phentermine free prescription Fluconazole Micronase Prochlorperazine Paris cheep phentermine Premphase Phentermine ionamin Herbal phentermine side effects Tramadol How much xanax is a lethal dose Proguanil Viagra cialis levivia comparison dosages Oxprenolol Itraconazole Mirapex Medication drug mylan online search phentermine diet Texas personal injury lawyers viagra Phentermine np Phentermine online stores Mexican pharmacies online+xanax Zantac Phentermine no perscription needed Nevirapine Cyclophosphamide Alfentanil Cheap phentermine online withour prescription Order xanax on line Buy cialis in uk Dofetilide Cordarone Canadian no phentermine prescription Xanax Herbal viagra alternative Nitroglycerin and viagra Viagra lawsuit Alternative viagra Cefuroxime Ativan re valium vs vs xanax Generic viagra from india Thiabendazole Didrex vs phentermine Nolvadex Free trial viagra Buy Butalbital Azithromycin Brompheniramine Repaglinide Is klonopin stronger than xanax Tramadol sales Phenylpropanolamine Buy xanax overnight Hydrocodone prescription Free viagra Atenolol Pulmonary hypertension and viagra Pravachol Free cialis Diet ky phentermine pill ship that Phentermine prescriptions online Benadryl Xanax 2 mg Phentermine cod overnight Botox Relafen Lanoxin Tegretol Phentermine pictures Tapering off xanax Buy prescription viagra Nafcillin Generic xanax 2mg Phentermine cash on delivery Pioglitazone Rabeprazole Phenylbutazone Order soma carisoprodol Phentermine hormone Cod free phentermine shipping Viagra 50 mg Phentermine message board Lamisil Buy discount viagra online Fact phentermine diet pill Viagra prescription online Buy phentermine pay cod Estrogen Buy consultation free hydrocodone online tramadol Xanax info Hydrocodone side effects vicodin Fda us approved phentermine Methoxsalen Ambien Phentermine diet pills diet pills Ketorolac Buy Paxil Xanax weight loss Cialis prices Imuran _achetez le viagra de levivia 2 mg xanax Zolpidem Levivia viagra vs Crestor Atracurium Heparin Cyber pharmacy phentermine What is xanax Detox hgh phentermine quit smoking xenical Mevacor Cheap xanax no prescription Donepezil What does xanax do Itraconazole Codeine Uk viagra supplier Cialis levitra viagra vs vs Klonopin Estraderm Xanax drug test Hydrocodone overdose Buy Lipitor Phentermine no perscription required Levallorphan Generic cialis from india Ramipril Overnight phentermine Bleomycin Viagra sales Urine drug testing of tramadol Buy cialis online Buy Celexa Review of herbal phentermine Triazolam Clarinex Long term effects of xanax Alavert Viagra buy viagra Oxycontin xanax bars perclesept and lortab wha Chlortrimeton Phentermine hydrochloride ship to missouri Effects of xanax Epo Crohns phentermine Prescriptions on line phentermine Buy cheap online uk viagra Canada online pharmacy viagra Recreational viagra use Xanax mexico Reserpine Cytomel Nolvadex Cialis order Estrogen Lisinopril with viagra Chlorprothixene Butalbital fioricet Buy phentermine in canada Viagra overnight Symptom of vicodin addiction Phentermine uses Danaparoid Buy in phentermine uk Ketoprofen Blue xanax Xanax drug interactions Adenosine Lowest phentermine prices Cheap online order viagra Compare cialis levitra viagra Buy viagra canada Xanax sexual side effects Xanax online pharmacy Cheapest place buy viagra online Viagra and blindness Cialis comparison levitra Importing cialis from canada to us Morphine Free phentermine Xanax demerol morphine no prescription needed Cialis for sale Mazindol Order tramadol Neurontin Geodon Clemastine Cardizem Dicumarol Naloxone Caverta veega generic viagra Compare prices on phentermine Free shipping with phentermine order Levitra Phentermine cheapest price Valium and xanax Cialis softtabs Thiothixene Phentermine sales online Viagra experiences Levothyroxine Buy phentermine prescription Amoxapine Perindopril Buy domain online 199mb com tramadol Viagra lowest price Imipramine Generic cialis overnight Best buy phentermine Tools needed for injecting xanax Non prescription phentermine Better than viagra Motrin Cheap phentermine no rx Flonase Phentermine overnight Levitra vs cialis vs viagra I need to identify pictures of phentermine Long term phentermine use Phentermine line Buy Cialis Phentermine blue capules Xanax cash on delivery Luvox Xanax drug information Carbarsone Clindamycin 180 phentermine Phentermine and sibutramine be combined Cialis comparison levivia viagra Oseltamivir Vicodin prescription Feldene Pepcid Information about viagra Viagra best buy Trichlormethiazide Cialis tadalafil Xanax paypal Nicorette Vicodin detox Dimenhydrinate Discount generic viagra Buying phentermine Meridia diet pill Insulin Zocor Pheniramine Probucol Phenyltoloxamine Buy Tylenol Amikacin Eldepryl Delivery generic overnight viagra Effects of viagra on woman Loracarbef Felbamate Buying xanax online Bromodiphenhydramine Buy xanax cod Mannitol Phentermine online purchase Imitrex Order generic cialis Viagra cialis levitra comparison Free viagra samples Free xanax Viagra alternative herbal supplement Hydrocodone dosage Order hydrocodone online Ativan Nylidrin Herbal alternatives to viagra Locoid Get phentermine Phentermine $89 Estraderm Generic viagra Cialis immunity Viagra cialis Paxil Cyclobenzaprine Hydroxyzine Fastin Buy cheap uk viagra Dicyclomine Niacinamide Glyburide Phentermine to buy Xenical hgh phentermine quit smoking Cheap phentermine online 37 5 _cialis et levitra Cheapest viagra price Pictures of xanax pills Order buy phentermine online Cheap tramadol cod free fedex About phentermine Xanax withdrawals Phentermine on line w&o prescription Lansoprazole Buy online phentermine shipping Free phentermine sample Phentermine fda Xanax on line Prescription viagra written Fioricet online Drug vicodin Buy Atarax Cialis levivia viagra compare Dulcolax Cefixime Avalide Phentermine no credit card cod Alternative herbal review viagra Buy Acyclovir Chlordiazepoxide Eprosartan Protonix Cheap cialis Mifepristone Buy phentermine online same day delivery Actos Viagra and high blood pressure Free try viagra Viagra without a prescription Meridia weight loss pill Buying viagra Soma Tramadol without prescription Piroxicam Phentermine pharmacy cod Phentermine 37.5 90 Phentermine insulin Micronase Prednisone Prazosin Phentermine results Plicamycin Buy xanax on line Phentermine ship to ky Buy online salescom viagra Low price phentermine Phentermine online prescription Cialis lowest price Best cialis price Sufentanil Metaraminol Cheap phentermine without prescription Cephalothin Purchase tramadol without a prescription Xanax dosage Oxycontin Phentermine risks Klonopin vs xanax dosage Phentermine pills Free viagra without prescription Cheap online phentermine prescription Mexican pharmacy phentermine Meridia Nasonex Shipping overnight phentermine Vicodin es Where to buy viagra Ibuprofen Compare phentermine Cheapest generic viagra Xanax doses Buy Zyrtec Diet in phentermine pill uk Xanax tablets Reviparin Natural viagra Dantrolene Withdraw xanax Vicodin online Cheap viagra order online Atropine Trifluoperazine Tramadol and online pharmacy Mycostatin Viagra advertisements Accupril Cialis testimonials Buy fioricet online Santa claus viagra jokes Xanax overnight delivery Hydrocodone bitartrate acetaminophen Phentermine sameday overnight saturday delivery Demeclocycline Phentermine cod shipping Ketamine Viagra and pulmonary hypertension Discount viagra sales Ganciclovir Mail order viagra Buy viagra now Pentobarbital Lopid Cefixime Buy generic online phentermine Doxycycline Tramadol pharmacy Tramadol dosage for dogs Azathioprine Norflex Symptom tramadol withdrawal


Molding hearts and minds

virginia tech350
I went to a memorial service today, held by Cornell in honor of the students and faculty killed Monday at Virginia Tech. Non-denominational university “services” aren’t the sort of thing I normally attend, and it actually seemed a little funny to me that a memorial service would be held at all, since we have no specific connection with Virginia Tech. But my choir had been asked to sing for it, and my section was short of available people. The time was convenient for me. So I went. And actually, a surprising number of people showed up for the service.

It wasn’t as bad as I expected. I identified no obvious blasphemy, and the speeches, though basically silly, were at least short. I wasn’t sure how to feel about the fact that my choir was singing the final segment, In Paradisum from the Durufle Requiem Mass. I mean, on the one hand, it was nice to be singing something genuinely religious (and even intended to be sung on behalf of the dead!) but of course it’s distressing to skip all the intermediate stages (the praising and humbling oneself and pleading to be delivered from eternal death) and cut straight to the happy wishes about being welcomed home by the saints and martyrs. On the whole, though, the former consideration wins out. It’s good to be singing a religious piece, and things could get a lot worse. (Last fall, for example, we were asked to sing at a memorial service on the anniversary of September 11, and the selected piece was the setting of some ridiculous poem whose message was basically, “Though I personally have a special affection for my own country, I should never forget to acknowledge that every other country is basically just like mine.” That seemed to me a deeply offensive message to be promoting in honor of the anniversary of a national tragedy, almost like going to the funeral of a child and hearing in the eulogy, “Well, you had a special fondness for her pretty hair and rosy cheeks, but after all there are pretty, rosy-cheeked five-year-olds all over the world so don’t think yours was anything special.” If families of victims attended – quite likely in upstate New York – would that be a comforting thing to hear? I skipped that service in protest.)

One part did make me rather uncomfortable: they asked a member of the local Korean church to sing a song, and made a big point of the fact that it was coming from the Koreans. That seemed rather insensitive to me, and I heard a couple of Korean students later saying more or less what I was thinking: why was it necessary to draw special attention to the fact that the shooter, Cho Seung-Hui, was a Korean immigrant? What difference does that make? I suppose it’s a sort of novelty since Americans aren’t used to seeing Asian culprits in horrible crimes like this, but you can hardly imagine that they would have asked a black student group to make a special contribution at the service had the shooter been black. Anyway, the really ridiculous thing about that song was the selection: Panis Angelicus. This coming from a member of an evangelical-type church, at a service in which the Angelic Bread was certainly nowhere in proximity. I suppose to them it was just a nice song in Latin, but I was certainly aware of the absurdity.

What’s really sad about such events, though, is to see the extreme impoverishment of a “spiritual” service in which there is no tradition to draw on and God cannot be mentioned. We get randomly-selected songs whose significance nobody in the crowd understands. At the front of the chapel sat a table with some burning candles on it, which was never mentioned or touched throughout the service — were they supposed to represent prayers? It was never clear. In the three speeches and reflections (one by a faculty member whose son attends Virginia Tech, one from President Skorton, and one from the provost, Biddy Martin) the message emphasized over and over was: Virginia Tech is an awesome school, and we feel lots of solidarity with them. That was the whole message. Go Hokies.

What else can you say, really? You can’t say that God loves the deceased and died for them, and that we’re praying for their salvation. You can’t reflect on the moral value of bearing the cross for His sake. That means, of course, that very little can be said about why their deaths might have been meaningful. You can’t promise that goodness will prevail on the last day, that the dead will rise again, that justice will be satisfied, mercy offered and the world renewed. With every genuinely comforting message ruled out, there really isn’t anything to say except… Go Hokies. Wear your maroon and orange tomorrow, kids.

Actually, if they were honest, a university might find a lot of material for reflection in a tragedy like this one. School shootings have become a recognized phenomenon in America; Monday’s massacre, though shocking in its way, nonetheless fit into an already-identifiable type. What does this say about our society and our educational system? We can talk about whether guns are too readily available, and whether video games are corrupting the minds of the youth, but beyond these cliché issues, surely there’s something more to be said about a societal phenomenon where every few years some alienated youth both feels and acts upon the impulse to kill his classmates.

One thing, at least, seems to be indicated, and the Doctor and I were discussing this today. We appear to have lost the notion of schools or universities as moral communities. Actually, outside of parishes or families, we may have lost moral communities altogether; certainly neighborhood blocks and workplaces don’t seem to function as such anymore. But for all the talk recently about what a wonderful and warm community Virginia Tech has, it’s obvious that everything couldn’t have been wonderful. One person at least was unhappy in Virginia. And when Cho Seung-Hui’s writing teacher brought some of his extremely disturbing work to the university administration suggesting that he might be psychologically unstable, the answer seems to have been, more or less, “Well, there’s nothing we can do about that.” The young man was, I believe, advised to seek counseling. He declined to do so, and that was the end of it. (I don’t mean to pick on Virginia Tech, by the way – I’m sure it would have been more or less the same at almost every other university in America.)

Well, you can’t arrest someone for writing nasty stories, but surely a college administration could do a little more? Could they, perhaps, make a psychiatric evaluation mandatory for students who show signs of being dangerous or unstable, and, for those who need it, make their attendance of counseling sessions mandatory under penalty of expulsion? Discussing this with the Doctor, I do remember Notre Dame being relatively proactive about looking after freshman students, at least. In my early months at the university I was required to have meetings with a whole slew of people (rector, RA, freshman advisor, senior undergraduate mentor, etc.) who all opened the conversation with the same question (“How are you adjusting?”) and asked me about my drinking habits. (I didn’t drink at all… still don’t.) I found this rather irksome at the time, since I felt perfectly fine and not in need of all these interviews, but in retrospect I can see the reasoning. I happened to be a “low risk” student, but the truth is that 18-year-olds are pretty immature and a lot of them probably need all the help the school can provide. Notre Dame also had some rules intended to raise the level of public morality. The no-sex rules were taken seriously and we had enforced parietals and quiet hours. In my dormitory we were not permitted to write obscene or offensive messages on other people’s marker boards, and students across the university were not permitted to hang pornographic pictures on their bedroom walls.

I do think, then, that Notre Dame was a good step up from many schools in the country, which isn’t to say that the environment was wholesome in every respect. But could a school like Cornell implement even relatively modest “morality” rules like Notre Dame’s? Attending a service like that, one tends to doubt it. In order to foster a moral community, the university would need some kind of moral foundation from which to draw. It is more than evident that they do not, and since they aren’t comfortable standing in loco parentis anyway, they’re not really looking for one. Students are customers, and customers can’t be told what to do, Given the sort of environment this creates, it’s not that surprising that particular people with poor social skills can come to see the university environment as The Enemy, nor is it surprising that such people are allowed to fester in their own hatred until every once in awhile they snap.

Youth ought to be a time when both intellectual and moral formation are given together. These can be mutually reinforcing when they are imparted simultaneously and in the right way. Schools like Cornell have virtually no hope of building such a model in any robust way, simply because they don’t have the spiritual resources, but others around the country might take note. Making people smarter without tending to their souls is a risky business.

President Skorton emphasized over and over in his speech today that Cornell and Virginia Tech are “of one family.” The idea seemed to be that they were alike merely in virtue of both being universities, and that made us a family. It seemed like a bit of a stretch to me at the time, but perhaps it really wasn’t. The memorial service itself, through its essentially vacuous nature, emphasized that Cornell is a community with no moral foundation, no sense of human purpose, and no resources for forming the characters of young people. Perhaps the same was true in Virginia.

12 Responses to “Molding hearts and minds”


  1. 1 Discipulus Apr 20th, 2007 at 8:00 pm

    Some memorial services have featured sending balloons up into the sky. Yes, “Go Hoakies,” says it all Clara. But be careful! The Greeks gave an example of how to counter anyone who would impiously belittle educational mores with irreverent questions. Modern day sages have already prescribed an antidote for disturbed students of today’s godless campus. The natural longing for God will be left void by the professors and filled most likely with an increased dose of Prozac and Ritalin. As with Socrates, such panaceas are proving fatal.

  2. 2 Mate