Archbishop Vincent Nichols: “Mothers no longer want their sons to be priests”

His Grace, the Archbishop of Birmingham, England, Vincent Nichols, has spent the past couple days visiting Oxford. Much like the Holy Father’s secretary, His Grace is a favorite among the fairer sex: “He is the Brad Pitt of the hierarchy with looks, charm and a Hollywood smile” said one recent news article. He makes me flustered also, but in a different way. He confirmed me at the Oxford Oratory two summers ago and gave me some memorable advice and in little conversations that day. He used to be regarded as a “liberal”, but he is now taking some things in the direction of tradition. During his tenure, he has returned the Tridentine Mass to Oxford, so that it is now not too difficult to go to the Traditional Latin Mass in Oxfordshire. This is really a big improvement as there used to be, when I first came here, no Tridentine Missae whatsoever in Oxford (except for the SSPX up in town). Now he appears as one obvious successor at Westminster and many people are openly talking about this possibility. He celebrated a beautiful sung Mass this morning at Blackfriars, the Dominican study house in Oxford, and the church was packed, even though the Mass was for a Colloquium of the Society of Saint Catherine of Siena. People follow and support him and enjoy being with him.


I think, for that reason, it’s great that we have his support for the more traditional devotions of the Church and for vocations to the priesthood. I especially like his comments on priesthood: “It’s a mistake to think that our priestly identity is something we put on, like a collar. It isn’t. Rather it’s something already written within us. It is who we are ‘from my mother’s womb’. Priestly identity is who we are, at the deepest level. It is both self-discovery and self-fulfilment.” Archbishop Nichols has been particularly emphasizing that “a renewed focus on the Blessed Sacrament” is most important, saying that those parishes with flourishing vocations have always had continual adoration of the Blessed Sacrament. He has concerns, however, that the young men who seek to pursue the priestly vocation are not supported by society or by their families. He continues, “I don’t see mothers promoting vocations in the same way. These young men are coming from a context of much less certainty. . mothers no longer want their sons to be priests.”

While other dioceses in England seem to be bending over backwards to encourage lay participation in the Church, Archbishop Nichols has been warmly welcomed by more traditional folk because he appears to be heading in the direction of tradition rather than towards a compromise with the bad elements of recent years. I, too, have high hopes for him.

5 Responses to “Archbishop Vincent Nichols: “Mothers no longer want their sons to be priests””


  1. 1 Iosephus Oct 30th, 2005 at 12:52 am

    Okay, I just don’t know if I can see why this guy, Nichols, is so popular with the ladies in England. Then again, I couldn’t see what the deal was with the Pope’s secretary, Msgr. Georg Ganswein. Off of the link in this post, I did find these pictures. The pictures are worth seeing, even if you’re already convinced that Msgr. Ganswein is a hunk, as they almost all include Cardinal Ratzinger and they’re rather original.

  2. 2 Stephen Oct 30th, 2005 at 1:37 am

    He is spot on with his assessment of vocations. I firmly believe that the seeds of vocations are planted at home from the faith and encouragement of the parents. I also feel that the lack of priests and religious in Catholic schools is part of the problem. Priests and religious need to be daily role models to children during their formative years, not just a weekly appearance at Mass.

    These are much more Catholic responses to the decline in clergy in some areas than married priests.

  3. 3 Doctor Asinorum Nov 1st, 2005 at 3:40 pm

    agree in not seeing why either of these guys are so great looking. But then again, I suppose we should be thankful that our Catholic women have such low standards.

    Anyway, one obvious (and oft mentioned, but I won’t let that stop me) thing regarding the decline in vocations is the decline in family size. It’s not surprising at all that a woman with one or two kids would not want her son to become a celibate priest. On the other hand, if you have 10 kids, or even 4-5, it seems like less of a loss (of potential grandchildren) to have one of your boys become a priest.

  4. 4 Catharina Nov 2nd, 2005 at 10:36 am

    >agree in not seeing why either of these guys are so great looking. But then again, I suppose we should be thankful that our Catholic women have such low standards.<

    Hey Doctor – Thank you for the humble analysis, but it’s not that we have “such low standards”; you boys are just ‘purely lucky’. ; )))

  5. 5 Clara Nov 2nd, 2005 at 10:43 am

    Seconding Catharina, I would add that you’re lucky that we concern ourselves more with your other commendable qualities than with your physical appearance.

Leave a Reply




Regina Sacratissimi Rosarii,
ora pro nobis

Dramatis Personae

Ambrosius
    Praeses Noster
Iacobus
    Sub-Praeses
Iosephus
    Magister Bibendi
Doctor Asinorum
    Poeta olim laureatus
Franciscus
    Praesidis Optio
Clara
    Legatus ad mulierculas
Bonifacius
    Vetus animus

    Contact Information

    information
    - at -
    cornellsociety.org
    cornellsociety on twitter


    Sententiae Legendae



    Religiosae Societates



    Loci Traditionalibus



    Bibliopollae Catholici



    Popinae Bene Edendi





    Patrons of our Society


    St. Louis-Marie de Montfort,
    ora pro nobis

    Pope St. Pius X,
    ora pro nobis


    Patrons of our Contributors


    St. Joseph,
    ora pro nobis

    St. Ambrose of Milan,
    ora pro nobis

    St. Thomas Aquinas,
    ora pro nobis

    St. Francis (and St. Clare),
    orate pro nobis

    St. Catherine of Siena,
    ora pro nobis

    St. Alphonsus Ligouri,
    ora pro nobis

    St. John Chrysostom,
    ora pro nobis
    see stats